Suddenly, the government of the United States has discovered the virtues of international law

George Monbiot again this week. He deals with the issue ot PoWs, and their rights. Monbiot questions the anger of the US administration at TV pictures of captured US soldiers – because they have done far worse to the prisoners of Guantanamo Bay.

His argument is telling here:

The US government claims that these men are not subject to the Geneva conventions, as they are not “prisoners of war”, but “unlawful combatants”. The same claim could be made, with rather more justice, by the Iraqis holding the US soldiers who illegally invaded their country. But this redefinition is itself a breach of article 4 of the third convention, under which people detained as suspected members of a militia (the Taliban) or a volunteer corps (al-Qaida) must be regarded as prisoners of war.

Monbiot then outlines even worse atrocities committed in Afghanistan, by Afghan warlords – with the apparent aid of US soldiers:

The US special forces running the prison watched the bodies being unloaded. They instructed Dostum’s men to “get rid of them before satellite pictures can be taken”. Doran interviewed a Northern Alliance soldier guarding the prison. “I was a witness when an American soldier broke one prisoner’s neck. The Americans did whatever they wanted. We had no power to stop them.” Another soldier alleged: “They took the prisoners outside and beat them up, and then returned them to the prison. But sometimes they were never returned, and they disappeared.”

As for Donald Rumsfeld calling for the Geneva Conventions to be upheld:

It should not be necessary to point out that hospitality of this kind also contravenes the third Geneva convention, which prohibits “violence to life and person, in particular murder of all kinds, mutilation, cruel treatment and torture”, as well as extra-judicial execution. Donald Rumsfeld’s department, assisted by a pliant media, has done all it can to suppress Jamie Doran’s film, while General Dostum has begun to assassinate his witnesses.


Posted

in

by

Tags: